Roughly how much could Charlton receive each year, and how could it be split?

What is the ballpark total?

This is an estimate for discussion. It is not a promise, not an offer, and not Charlton's number. We do not have a Charlton figure, and our tax and assessment research is still open. Three Massachusetts agreements, in Carver, Revere, and Medway, work out to roughly $9,300 to $11,300 per megawatt per year. At 150 megawatts, that range comes to about $1.4 to $1.7 million a year. The amount is the town's to negotiate. In this estimate it is one total: protections come off the top first, and what is left is the town fund.

How did other towns arrive at their amounts?

Each town negotiated its own deal. The $9,300 to $11,300 per megawatt range combines every yearly payment each town gets from its project, the PILOT plus any separate host community agreement, averaged over 20 years.

  • Carver built its payment from a rate of $10,000 per megawatt plus a yearly increase, then leveled it into equal payments of $1,690,000 a year for 20 years. It covers the equipment only, and the town still taxes the land separately. We have not found a separate benefits agreement for Carver, so the range uses its PILOT alone.
  • Medway hired an independent valuation consultant, who laid out the assessed value and tax rate behind the payment so the town could compare it with ordinary taxes. The PILOT pays $2,237,714 a year for 20 years, plus an extra 3 percent of each payment to make up the Community Preservation Act surcharge. A separate host community agreement adds emergency preparedness funding, fire department training, money for the town's own consultants, property value protection for nearby homes, and a decommissioning bond. The PILOT is conditioned on approval by Town Meeting, and the posted copy is unsigned.
  • Revere has a fixed PILOT schedule that starts at $1.5 million a year and steps up 2.5 percent every five years, plus a separate host community agreement that starts at $600,000 a year. In the first year, $600,000 of the host community agreement and $617,000 of the PILOT go to fire equipment. The posted copies are unsigned versions from the city council packet for June 22, 2026.
  • Chelsea is not included. Its city council agenda for June 24, 2024 lists an order for a PILOT and a host community agreement, but the signed agreements are not public, so the amounts cannot be checked.

All three were negotiated under the older state rules, and each project differs from Charlton, so none carries over as a number. The agreements are in the Document Library under Other Towns' Agreements.

How do I use the estimate?

The chart shows one total. Protections off the top show as a gray slice, and the rest is the town fund, split among the uses residents picked on September 30. Move a slider to change one item's share, and the others adjust to stay at 100 percent. Uncheck an item to take it out, and use Add to put it back at 5 percent. Open Options to lock a share; a locked share does not change. Reset returns to the starting split. The table shows each item, its share, and an estimated range per year, rounded to the nearest $10,000.

Below the chart, start from the Lowest or Highest figures or one town's terms, then move a slider. Each protection can be paid once or every year, as a fixed amount or up to a cap. Well testing is a cost for a well, times 8 properties or 11 properties, and the well fund shows how many new wells it is enough for. Count the property value protection fund per property or per home to see the most it could pay from its starting fund. A town with no figure for an item shows not in this town's agreement. Your totals, kept apart, show what comes off the top every year, what comes off the top once, what is left for the town fund, also in year 1, and what is held as a guarantee. Nothing you choose here is saved or sent.

One total

Protections off the top: $26,920 a year$1.4 to $1.7million a year

Protections off the top: $26,920 a year

Town fund: $1,370,000 to $1,670,000 a year, before these:

Not yet priced (6)Post-construction reviews · Committee's meeting costs · Community liaison · Incident escrow · Enforcement fund · Road repair bond
What comes off the top for protections?
  • 32%

    $440,000 to $530,000

  • 27%

    $370,000 to $450,000

  • 27%

    Not in the plan yet

    $370,000 to $450,000

  • 14%

    $190,000 to $230,000

ItemShareEstimated range per year
Money for the town budget32%$440,000 to $530,000
Conservation land and habitat27%$370,000 to $450,000
Help with home energy costsNot in the plan yet27%$370,000 to $450,000
Senior and community center14%$190,000 to $230,000
Protections off the top$26,920 a year
Total100%$1.4 to $1.7 million

What comes off the top for protections?

The project's payments are one total. Protections come off the top first, and what is left is the town fund the Select Board splits, so every dollar set aside for protections is a dollar the Select Board does not assign. The sliders below use figures from Medway, Tewksbury, Revere, and MassDEP.

What did other towns set for these items?

Three agreements in the Document Library put dollar figures on some protections: Medway, Tewksbury, and Revere. Two more items are priced from MassDEP's 2026 private well report. Every other item is amount set with the committee.

  • Fire equipment and training. Tewksbury pays $80,000 once for technical rescue equipment. Medway pays for a fire department training position instead, $247,500 over four years. Revere puts $1,217,000 of its first-year payments toward fire apparatus, and pays $150,000 separately at the start of construction.
  • Yearly fire training allowance. Revere pays up to $25,000 a year for refresher training. Medway pays up to $40,000 a year for training, emergency preparedness and fire suppression materials. Tewksbury pays up to $60,000 a year for public safety training and fire suppression materials.
  • Routine well testing and the private well protection fund. MassDEP 2026: $240 a routine test and $756 a first full test with PFAS, per well (Table A-2). MassDEP 2026: about $21,000 a new well and $4,000 for whole-house treatment (Tables A-5 and A-7). Testing covers 8 properties, or 11 properties if three more homes on T. Hall Road share the drainage.
  • Property value protection fund. Medway pays up to $25,000 per home within 300 feet, from a $50,000 fund kept topped up. Tewksbury pays up to $25,000 per home within 650 feet, from a $50,000 fund kept topped up. The draft plan's 1,000-foot line takes in 6 properties, or 10 to 14 homes.
  • Decommissioning bond. Required by the permit conditions and sized by an independent estimate, so it cannot be adjusted here. Medway's and Tewksbury's starting bonds work out to about $3,000,000 to $7,200,000 at 150 megawatts.

These are other towns' terms and state costs, for context, not offers for Charlton.

Start from
  • Yearly fire training allowanceUp to $25,000 a year
  • $240 × 8 = $1,920 a year

    MassDEP 2026: $240 a routine test and $756 a first full test with PFAS, per well (Table A-2).

  • Enough for 1 new well · held as a guarantee

    MassDEP 2026: about $21,000 a new well and $4,000 for whole-house treatment (Tables A-5 and A-7).

  • Property value protection fundUp to $25,000 per home
    6 properties

    Most it could pay: $150,000 · Starting fund $50,000

  • Decommissioning bondRequired$3,000,000

    Required by the permit conditions and sized by an independent estimate, so it cannot be adjusted here.

  • Amount set with the committee

    Post-construction reviews · Committee's meeting costs · Community liaison · Incident escrow · Enforcement fund · Road repair bond

Can I add something that is not in this estimate?

Yes. To suggest an item, comment on the draft Community Benefits Plan or use the comment form on carpenterhillpower.com. Comments are open into 2027, and we respond to every comment in writing.

How does the money move?

Everything starts as one total of about $1.4 to $1.7 million a year. Protections come off the top and are paid directly, set aside in a fund or escrow, or guaranteed by bonds. What is left is the town fund, which the Select Board splits. The table shows when the money moves and who decides. The decommissioning bond sits outside the total because the permit requires it.

Who decides each protection?
  • Paid directly, paid by the project as costs come up: fire equipment and training before the facility starts, with the Fire Chief deciding what the department needs; a yearly fire training allowance paid to the town, also decided by the Fire Chief; routine well testing, on a schedule set by the Board of Health; post-construction reviews, with the town's departments; the committee's meeting costs, with the agenda set by the committee; and a community liaison, named by the project owner.
  • Fund or escrow, set aside ahead of time: the private well protection fund, drawn on by the Board of Health; the incident escrow and the enforcement fund, drawn on by the Select Board; and a property value protection fund for close neighbors for five years after operation starts, with claims decided by an independent appraiser.
  • Bonds, posted before work starts: the road repair bond, with repairs scoped by the Highway Department; and the decommissioning bond, which is required by the permit conditions, sits outside the total, and pays for taking the facility down at its end of life.

What is left is the town fund, paid into one fund every operating year. The table shows when the money moves, before construction, during construction, in operating years, at reviews at 1, 5 and 10 years, and at the end of life, and who decides how it is used. Each item links to its card in the draft Community Benefits Plan.

When the money moves
ItemBefore constructionDuring constructionOperating yearsReviews at 1, 5 and 10 yearsEnd of lifeWho decides
Town fundThe Select Board
Paid directly
Fire equipment and trainingThe Fire Chief
Yearly fire training allowanceThe Fire Chief
Routine well testingThe Board of Health
Post-construction reviewsThe town's departments
Committee's meeting costsThe committee
Community liaisonThe project owner
Fund or escrow
Private well protection fundThe Board of Health
Incident escrowThe Select Board
Enforcement fundThe Select Board
Property value protection fundAn independent appraiser
Bonds
Road repair bondThe Highway Department
Decommissioning bondRequiredThe permit conditions

What is a PILOT, and why use one?

PILOT stands for payment in lieu of taxes. A battery project loses value on paper as the equipment ages, so ordinary property taxes shrink over time. A PILOT sets a predictable payment each year instead. Developers like it for the same reason towns do: both know what to expect. For Charlton, the draft Community Benefits Plan names the Select Board and the Board of Assessors as negotiating it with the project owner. Other towns have agreed to 20-year terms.

What would a PILOT look like over 20 years?

Use the PILOT schedule to try a PILOT rate per megawatt and a term of 10 to 30 years. Choose flat, like Medway, or steps up every five years, like Revere. Neither rises with inflation. The chart shows each year's payment, the year 1 payment, and the year total. These are other towns' terms; Charlton's are the town's to negotiate.

PILOT schedule

$10,300
$9,300$11,300
20 years
10 years30 years

Year 1 payment

$1,545,000

20-year total

$30,900,000

$0$0.5M$1.0M$1.5M$2.0M15101520
What is the difference between a benefit and a protection?

A benefit is something Charlton gets on top of what the project has to do, such as conservation funding or support for a senior and community center. A protection goes beyond required mitigation, but exists because of the project's own impacts, such as routine well testing, post-construction reviews for the town, an enforcement fund, and an incident escrow. In this estimate, protections come out of the same total as the town fund, before the town splits the rest.

Who decides how the money is split?

The town and the project decide together how much of the total goes to protections, and which protections go into a signed agreement. What is left is the town fund, paid into one fund that the Select Board controls, and the Select Board decides how it is split. Public comments and the draft Community Benefits Plan are a guide for that decision. The draft plan does not have dollar figures yet.

Where does the starting split come from?

The starting split follows how often each topic was picked at the September 30 public forum, with both sessions combined: money for the town budget, 11 picks; conservation land and habitat, 9; help with home energy costs, 9; and senior and community center, 5. Fire equipment and training drew 7 picks. In this estimate it is a protection that comes off the top, so it does not take a share of the town fund. One write-in pick for free EV charging is left out. These are picks from a small group, not points and not a vote. The activity is advisory only. It is not a budget and not a commitment.

Is help with home energy costs in the plan?

Not in the plan yet. In the draft it is an open question for the committee, not a commitment. It is shown here because residents picked it on September 30.

What is not in this estimate?

The decommissioning bond is not part of the total. It is required by the permit conditions and pays for taking the facility down at its end of life. Six protections have no figure in the three agreements we compared or in a state cost report, so each one is an amount set with the committee: post-construction reviews, the committee's meeting costs, the community liaison, the incident escrow, the enforcement fund, and the road repair bond. The chart lists them as not yet priced. Once they are set, they also come off the top, so the town fund the chart shows is before these.