Question and Submission History

Original questions and earlier responses, linked to the consolidated answer bank.

Back to questions and answers

This history preserves the anonymized wording and earlier written responses in the imported project records. Earlier responses may describe a previous design or contain wording now under review. Use the linked consolidated question for the current response status.

A source record can contain several questions. These records are not a count of individual submissions or people. Original messages and dates are still being reconciled; this history does not establish that every project submission has been captured.

Showing 12 of 211 source records

Public Community Meeting #1 · July 8, 2026I am concerned about how it is going to affect my house, my land, and my well. It is in my backyard.

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier published response, not current

We prioritize protecting your home, land, and water. Siting battery systems requires strict adherence to MassDEP stormwater regulations. We designed the site grading so that all surface runoff drains away from neighboring homes and is captured within dedicated, lined retention basins. Under state law, the post-development runoff rate cannot exceed the pre-development rate. For a well located to the north and uphill of the equipment footprint, the natural slope directs surface drainage away from the well, and our hydrological studies will confirm how groundwater moves across the site. We are also constructing a continuous catchment swale along the southern boundary to capture and filter any surface runoff before it can reach adjacent properties.

An updated answer is now available: How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Public Community Meeting #1 · July 8, 2026Are you aware our town’s wells were contaminated by Exxon Mobil in the past, pretty severely?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier published response, not current

Yes, we are fully aware of the severe impact that the past Exxon Mobil MTBE contamination had on Charlton's private wells. We respect how sensitive groundwater issues are for local families. To prevent any contamination risk, our site design employs multiple physical barriers. The battery containers use sealed steel enclosures with built-in containment pans to capture any fluids. Furthermore, we are designing our stormwater management system in compliance with MassDEP's strict groundwater protection standards, preventing any untreated runoff from soaking into the water table. We will also participate in regular groundwater monitoring program protocols established with the local Board of Health.

Updated answers are now available: How will firefighting water be kept out of wells? · Is the old gas station spill related to this project?

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Is the old gas station spill related to this project?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Public Community Meeting #1 · July 8, 2026How will you mitigate a lightning strike causing a catastrophic failure? How will you contain fire-water runoff from poisoning the town’s wells? What are your plans for a fire-water pond for the fire department? And if there is no pond, where will the fire department get the water?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

This written response was added after the July 8 meeting. At the meeting, this question got a promise to follow up, not this answer. Its sentence about a continuous concrete foundation and a lined drainage swale is wrong: it does not describe the project's design. Use the current answers linked here.

Earlier published response, not current

On lightning strike mitigation: We install specialized surge arresters and active grounding grids that meet NFPA 780 lightning protection standards. We are also adding a lightning transient analysis to our electrical safety models to verify the system can isolate and ground a strike without damage.

On fire-water runoff containment: Modern safety protocols for lithium-ion battery fires recommend letting a single contained cabinet burn out rather than spraying huge amounts of water. In past industry incidents, the firefighting water itself, not the fire, created contaminated runoff. If the fire department must use water to cool adjacent units, a continuous concrete foundation and a lined drainage swale will capture and contain the runoff for safe disposal.

On the water supply and fire pond: Siting a battery system under NFPA 855 does not require a dedicated fire-water pond on site. We are coordinating directly with Charlton Fire Chief Rob Barton to determine the exact water supply, dry hydrant, and equipment needs. If required, we will construct a dedicated cistern or dry-hydrant connection point at the developer's expense.

Updated answers are now available: Where will firefighters get water? Will there be a fire pond? · How will a lightning strike be kept from causing a fire?

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Where will firefighters get water? Will there be a fire pond?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will a lightning strike be kept from causing a fire?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Community Public Forum · September 30, 2026Would firefighters just let it burn?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier published response, not current

Fire experts advise against spraying water on a burning battery unit. The response being planned is defensive: keep people back, protect the surroundings, and monitor the air while the unit burns out. It is not "doing nothing." Firefighters would work to keep the fire from reaching anything else, and the test reports show why a unit can be left to burn out. In the most extreme test on the Megapack 2 and 2XL, the fire stayed in one cabinet. Water is still used. It can cool equipment next to the burning unit, and a water spray can help knock down smoke from the plume. It is kept off the burning unit itself, because water that touches it can pick up contaminants. Any firefighting water used is captured on site.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Would firefighters just let it burn?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · Submission date not confirmedHow will you contain the fire water run-off and prevent the run-off water from poisoning the local well water?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

Two commitments are in place. Firefighting water is to be captured on an impermeable surface so it cannot reach groundwater, and runoff along the southern boundary is to be captured. Testing and removal procedures for captured water are part of the Emergency Action Plan being developed with Charlton Fire, which an independent reviewer selected by the town will examine at the project's cost. A groundwater study and a groundwater monitoring program are also committed.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · July 7, 2026, 8:32 AM ETToxic emissions, contamination of water, soil, air.

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

In normal operation nothing is burned, so the facility gives off no smoke or emissions. The batteries use lithium iron phosphate, which has no cobalt or nickel. The concern is a fire. Smoke from a battery fire can contain carbon monoxide and hydrogen fluoride. A gas plume analysis is committed and has not been published, so no road or home can be described as unaffected yet. The site is to have spill containment and stormwater management, firefighting water is to be captured on site, and a groundwater monitoring program is committed.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • What substances could be released in a fire or failure?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · September 18, 2026, 2:18 PM ET2) if there is this type of runoff thru the cabs where does that water go? Is it possible it could have toxins in it? Is it captured and disposed of somehow?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

Water on the equipment area, including firefighting water, is to be captured on a hard surface and directed to containment so it does not soak into the ground. Water that has passed through equipment in a fire could carry contaminants, which is why capture is committed. Test results on that water have not been published. Disposal procedures are part of the Emergency Action Plan, and the groundwater monitoring program would check for any impact.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Vent panels, water inside the cabinet, sensor power
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · September 10, 2026, 9:13 AM ETWater- Facilities like this one are known to use and pollute large quantities of water. Charlton, MA has a history of pollutants in the water and some difficulty maintaining clean water. What specific methods do you have to ensure you do not take water from the local community and that it stays clean through construction and beyond? How will you compensate the neighborhood of Carpenter Hill Road and other residents of Charlton, MA if you negatively impact water supply, electricity costs, or accessibility? "Negatively impact" to be defined by the Charlton, MA community.

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

Keeping the water supply and its quality protected. Normal operation is not expected to draw on the town's drinking water. Plans for erosion control, stormwater management, and groundwater monitoring are being developed. Spill containment is planned, and firefighting water is to be captured on site, not released to groundwater or drainage areas. The detailed hydrology and stormwater studies are still being completed and will be made available when they are.

Compensation. The draft Community Benefits Plan proposes that the project pay to test eligible private wells within 1,000 feet of the work limit, and that if a test shows a change linked to the site, the project pay for bottled water within 48 hours and for treatment or a replacement well. This is a draft and not yet a commitment. No promise has been made on electricity costs or accessibility. The draft plan is the place to define what counts as a negative impact, and comments on it are open into 2027.

Update, November 18, 2026. This answer says the draft plan proposes bottled water within 48 hours. Separately, if oil or a hazardous material reached a drinking water well serving a home, Massachusetts cleanup rules presume that the immediate response must stop or reduce that exposure, and they list a temporary alternative water supply as one way to do it (310 CMR 40.0414). Those rules do not set a number of hours. The 48-hour timeline is the draft plan's own. An updated answer is now available: Will my well be tested, and who pays if it changes?

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Will the facility use local water or change the water table?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · August 4, 2026What substances could be released from damaged batteries, transformers, cooling equipment, or firefighting operations?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

A damaged battery could vent hydrogen, carbon monoxide, and other hydrocarbons, along with smaller amounts of hydrogen fluoride and related fluorinated compounds from the electrolyte and binder. The facility's LFP chemistry does not contain cobalt or nickel, but that does not remove this risk, since it originates in a different part of the cell. A damaged transformer could release its dielectric oil, typically mineral or synthetic ester and not PCB-containing in modern equipment. Damaged cooling equipment could release glycol coolant or a fluorinated refrigerant. Firefighting operations mainly risk contaminated runoff carrying dissolved metals, fluoride, and soot particulates, which is why on-site containment and boundary drainage measures are already committed.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • What substances could be released in a fire or failure?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · August 4, 2026What would happen to contaminated water used during a battery fire? How would it be captured, tested, removed, and prevented from entering groundwater, wetlands, or nearby wells?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

Two commitments are already in place: water used to fight a fire will be captured on an impermeable surface so it cannot reach groundwater, and runoff along the southern boundary will be captured. Testing and removal procedures are part of the emergency management plan being developed with the Charlton Fire Department, which the town's independently selected reviewer will also examine, at no cost to the town.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · Submission date not confirmedWould firefighters just let it burn?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

Fire experts advise against spraying water on a burning battery unit. The response being planned is defensive: keep people back, protect the surroundings, and monitor the air while the unit burns out. It is not "doing nothing." Firefighters would work to keep the fire from reaching anything else, and the test reports show why a unit can be left to burn out. In the most extreme test on the Megapack 2 and 2XL, the fire stayed in one cabinet.

Water is still used. It can cool equipment next to the burning unit, and a water spray can help knock down smoke from the plume. It is kept off the burning unit itself, because water that touches it can pick up contaminants. Any firefighting water used is captured on site.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Would firefighters just let it burn?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
Website and email · Submission date not confirmedMy street has no town water. How would firefighters get water for a fire?

Editor's note: there is a better, updated answer.

The response below is kept as a record of what was said at the time. It may describe an earlier design or wording that has since been corrected. Use the current answer instead:

Earlier written draft, not current (answers as of October 7, 2026)

Firefighting water would be needed at the site, not on your road. We have committed to capture firefighting water on site, on a hard surface, so it cannot reach groundwater. We have also committed to plan the fire water supply with the Fire Chief. Storing water at the site to match what fire trucks can deliver is one option. Charlton Fire has confirmed there is no hydrant system at the site and that water would be trucked in, or the town could consider extending the water line from Route 169. That is the town's decision and it has not been made.

How the issues were handled

A written response is recorded. Sending an individual reply, considering feedback, and making a design change require separate evidence.

  • Where will firefighters get water? Will there be a fire pond?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.
  • How will firefighting water be kept out of wells?
    Individual reply: not confirmed. Consideration: not recorded. Design change: not confirmed.